Beside Corin Ashby, "as always", and the one of the pair who keeps looking.
The introduction
Ch. 258, across a courtyard, with no dialogue at all.
Corin's glance at Arthur's table is "the particular practiced disinterest of someone who wanted it clearly understood that he had noticed something and equally clearly understood that he did not care to comment on it".
Talon's is different, and the chapter spends more words on it:
Talon, beside him, held the look a moment longer. There was something in his expression that Arthur couldn't quite place, not quite curiosity and not quite judgment, something closer to simple observation, the particular attention of someone cataloging information without yet deciding what to do with it.
Then he says something to Corin "that made the other boy's mouth curve into a thin, unreadable smile".
That is the entirety of his first appearance. He watches, and he is not hostile, and the chapter declines to say what he is.
He recalculates too
Ch. 260, after the duel. Corin leaves the ring and Talon looks back once.
something in his expression that had not been there before the duel began, a small, private recalculation quietly taking place behind otherwise unreadable features.
He said nothing. He simply looked, and then followed Corin from the yard.
Not from the yard: the duels from the same slate go on, and in ch. 263 Sutton calls Talon to fight Mira while Corin watches from the sidelines. The archive's corrected edition of ch. 260 has "from the ring". The line is still wrong on Wattpad.
His one line in the chapter is to Corin, before it starts:
TLN: That should be interesting.
Two appearances, two long looks, three words of dialogue. The saga is deliberately withholding him.
He forfeits rather than hit Mira
Ch. 263. Sutton pairs him against Mira, who holds a practice sword "with the particular loose, uncertain grip of someone who had spent considerably more time reading about combat than practicing it".
Elsie calls it before it starts:
ELS: Talon's never once looked at her without going slightly soft in the face. Watch.
He does not move at all.
MRA: You're supposed to attack. TLN: I know. MRA: Then why aren't you. TLN: I can't. [...] I don't want to hit you.
TLN: You can win. I concede.
He does not hedge it when pressed:
MRA: You're supposed to try. TLN: I did try. I tried very hard, for about four seconds, to imagine swinging a sword at you, and I found I simply couldn't manage it.
MRA: You could at least pretend. TLN: I'm not very good at pretending. It's rather a flaw of mine.
And he takes the grade for it:
SUT: Pryce. This is a graded exercise. TLN: I understand, sir. I accept whatever grade that earns me. I still can't do it.
Mira walks past him "with her cheeks faintly, unmistakably pink, and did not look back to see the small, helpless smile Talon wore as he watched her go".
This is the first time he says anything of substance, and it is a refusal.
Why he stands beside Corin
Ch. 272, on the rooftop, is the first time he explains himself.
TLN: I've spent most of my life standing beside Corin. Watching people look at him first, always, the way people look at anyone born into something enormous. I don't resent it. I chose it, in a way, choosing to stay close to someone who was always going to be looked at before I was.
And why Mira:
TLN: You're the first person here who didn't look at either of us first. You looked past both of us, mostly, the way you look past most things, and I found I didn't mind it. I found I rather liked it, actually, being someone you had to be coaxed into noticing rather than someone noticed automatically because of who I stand beside.
His full answer for the ch. 263 concession:
TLN: I think, somewhere in the middle of that duel, I understood that hurting you, even in play, even with a padded blade, would have meant treating you like everyone else treats you. Like something to be handled carefully from a distance, or overcome, or managed. I didn't want to be one more person who approached you that way.
He admits the following without apology:
TLN: I followed you. Twice. [...] I got tired of pretending I didn't know where you disappeared to most evenings. MRA: You could have just asked. TLN: Would you have said yes? MRA: Probably not. TLN: There you go, then.
He waits
Ch. 297. He takes Mira to a cat cafe, admits he has been twice alone, and does not explain why she is the person he wanted to bring.
He never asks her what she is. When she tells him anyway, he says why:
TLN: I've been deliberately not asking for a while now, actually. [...] Because you'd tell me when you wanted to. And you did. That seemed considerably better than pressing for it earlier and getting something you'd rather not have given.
Her reaction is the same one she had on the rooftop:
the particular disorienting sensation of being handled correctly by someone who seemed to require no instruction on how to do it.
And he asks for the chess game:
MRA: I sacrificed a rook. On the twenty-fourth move. TLN: Is that impressive? MRA: Extremely. TLN: Then tell me about it properly. I'd like to hear it.
Ch. 328
First to act, before anybody has finished shouting, and the only line in the chapter in full capitals:
TLN: BEHIND IT. EVERYONE BEHIND IT.
He is already moving as he says it, "catching Finn's arm and Briar's collar and putting both of them bodily behind the stone".
He is also the one who reports Yseult honestly rather than gently:
TLN: She's finished. MRA: How finished? TLN: Mira, she's on the floor.
And when Mira, standing alone on open stone in front of a thing she has just talked down, asks for somebody to come and stand near her:
Talon was there before she finished the sentence.
Four volumes of being patient at a distance, and the one time she asks, there is no distance left to cross.
Beckwith
Ch. 321 to ch. 323. He is one of the eight sent to a village of forty buildings with no list and nobody checking on them. See Beckwith.
Ch. 329: the arm, and the ten minutes
Two things, both of which he does without comment.
Coming down off the hill he and Corin take Yseult in turns, "one on each side for the steep sections and one carrying her outright across the loose scree above the high pasture".
And Mira, who insists on walking, walks the whole way with his hand closed around her upper arm and does not once suggest he let go.
That evening she eats something and goes up, and he goes up ten minutes later, "and had been extremely casual about the interval, which fooled nobody and was not, Arthur thought, entirely meant to".
Ch. 330: the chapter is named after him and he says twenty words in it
Mira tells the long table what she is. Seven people hear it for the first time. Elsie is the one who works out what that means about the eighth, "without any particular emphasis, which is how she said everything".
ELS: Talon didn't ask.
Everyone looked at Talon. Talon looked back with the unbothered composure of a person who had been waiting some time for exactly this.
TLN: No. ELS: You knew. TLN: Yes. ELS: How long? TLN: A while.
He did not elaborate, and it became apparent, over the next several seconds and with no assistance from him whatsoever, that he was not going to.
BRR: How long is a while, Talon. TLN: A while, Briar.
He never says how long. Ch. 297 has him tell Mira "I've been deliberately not asking for a while now, actually", and that is still the whole of it from him. Mira is the one who puts a date on it:
MRA: He's been deliberately not asking things since before the harvest market.
The harvest market is ch. 269. So it starts before the rooftop in ch. 272, which is the first time she told him anything about herself at all, and twenty-eight chapters before the cat cafe where he explained the habit to her.
The line
TLN: I've been deliberately not asking things my entire life. You're the first person who's noticed.
That is the largest thing the saga has said about him, and it reframes everything above it. Ch. 297 reads as patience extended to one person who needed it. This says it is not a courtesy at all, it is how he is, and "most of my life standing beside Corin" in ch. 272 is the same fact seen from the outside. Nobody had noticed until somebody who has spent her whole life being handled carefully was handled correctly and knew the difference.
Arthur, watching Mira rather than Talon, reads her face:
probably the closest thing to being safe that a person like her ever got: seven people finding out at once that somebody had known for months and had simply never once mentioned it to any of them.
The chapter is named for him. "The Only One Who Didn't Ask" is the title, and his entire part in it is one refusal, four one-word answers and two sentences.
Ch. 332: he says the thing nobody has said
Ch. 330 is about what he does not ask. This is the one time in the saga he asks, and it costs him more than any of the not-asking did.
Twelve weeks after the Trial of Power, on the last night, with the village gone home and the fourth lamp lit, he puts his cup down and looks across the table at Corin.
TLN: Corin. COR: Mm. TLN: We're going back tomorrow. COR: I'm aware. TLN: I'd rather we had this here than there.
The timing is the whole of the thought. Four hours from Solmere, on the last night, in a room where nobody is anybody's family name. Arthur is surprised it is Talon and then, an hour later, is not.
TLN: You put a man face-down on the ground in front of four hundred people and told him what he was, and then you told them, and Sutton had to stop you. And nobody has said one word about it for twelve weeks, and I've not said anything because I've never once had to say anything to you before and I don't know how it's done. COR: You're doing it adequately. TLN: I'm doing it terribly. I've been rehearsing it since the beck.
Since the beck is ch. 329 at the earliest, so he has been carrying it for the whole back half of the week.
This is ch. 272 turned round. There he told Mira he had spent most of his life standing beside Corin and had chosen it, and that he did not resent being looked at second. Standing beside somebody is also the position from which nobody ever has to say anything hard to them, and twelve weeks of that is what he is ending.
He does not push it further than it needs to go. When Corin finishes, "Talon nodded once and picked his cup back up, and that was the whole of it".
His last line in the exchange is the one that refuses Corin the old exemption:
COR: I simply assumed that whatever I did would be read charitably, because it always has been. TLN: It's not going to be, now. COR: No. Nor should it.
Ch. 333: the arrangement
He walks the eastern road next to Mira, and the chapter gives it one clause: "Mira walked next to Talon. Nobody remarked on it, which had become the arrangement."
Castelgard for the summer with Corin.
Later, from the author's notes chapters nobody has read yet
Nothing in the notes describes him beyond the group he travels with, which the chapters have now written.
His Requiem is Lucky Man
This is a plan, not canon. No chapter has reached it. The author chose it in a planning session.
The name. Lucky Man, a song by The Verve. Bitter Sweet Symphony is a song by The Verve too, so his ability and his Requiem come from one band. The name also answers Corin in ch. 319: "You are not the strongest thing in this academy. You are the luckiest." Dane was lucky because he got everything for nothing. Talon gets his Requiem by giving up his place each time he uses it.
What it does. Bitter Sweet Symphony routes what fills a gap. In the Requiem, Talon becomes the thing that fills it. When a thing in his chord is moved, ruined, or changed, he is what comes to take its place. He does not cross the distance. He is already there.
This gives him very high speed, but not as running. A witness cannot say that they saw him move. The seed is ch. 352, which reads ch. 328 again:
Mira asking for somebody to stand near her, "and Talon there before she finished the sentence. Before. Not quickly. Before."
It also grows out of the moment in ch. 352 when he "very nearly" becomes something larger, which goes back "a long way down" until he is ready to fetch it. The Requiem is that.
What it removes. Raske found the limit of the ability in ch. 352: "You need me to move first." The Requiem removes the limit. Talon makes the gap himself, where he wants to be, as he did once on purpose in ch. 352, and then he fills it.
What it costs. Each place he fills leaves the place he came from empty, and nothing comes to fill it. It is the one gap that the harmony does not close, because he is the thing that would go there.
Why it suits him. In the plan for the attack of the Pinkies, his team does the support and the evacuation of the city. Since ch. 352 the whole character is a boy who stands in the place where somebody is supposed to be.
Open in the plan:
- When it awakens. The attack of the Pinkies is the likely place, but the author has not set it.
- Whether the empty place is permanent, or closes when the Requiem ends.
- Who sees it first. Mira is the reading that ch. 328 and ch. 352 support.
See Soul Requiem.
Ch. 335: the longer goodbye
He leaves with Corin at eight, and takes longer over it, "because Talon's always did".
a genuinely startling hug for Mira that she permitted and then stood very still through, and a quiet word to her that Arthur did not hear and did not ask about.
The archive does not have the word and will not guess at it.
Ch. 347: the bottom of the hill
He rides home to Castelgard with Corin and leaves him at the bottom of the hill, because the Pryce house is on the eastern side of the town and "there was nothing to be gained by putting off either of their homecomings by riding up together".
He gives Corin one evening's grace, and names it for what it is:
COR: That's cowardly advice. TLN: It's kind advice. They look quite similar from a distance.
Corin does not take it. He tells his father the whole of the final before the soup.
Ch. 348: the blue door
The saga's first look inside his home. A narrow grey house with a door painted blue "by somebody who was not a painter". His mother is Agnes Pryce, "a small, quick woman who moved about her kitchen as though it had personally offended her by being too large". She has written to him every week since the closures and he has written back every week.
She asks Corin about everything except the Trial, and the father is not mentioned either. There is one chair at the table nobody uses, "which had been true for as long as Corin had been coming to this house".
Then she breaks a cup, and there are still three on the tray:
Two were the same blue as the door, and the third was older and plainer and chipped at the lip, and he could not have said where it had come from or when it had arrived.
AGN: You've still got that little habit, then. TLN: It's not a habit. AGN: It's never been anything else, love. Drink your tea.
Corin realises he has seen it a hundred times: a glove lent one winter while Talon somehow still had two, an inkwell knocked over in their first month that was full again by the end of the lesson.
There is a half written letter on the table, and he covers it with a book "as a man puts his hand over a cup".
AGN: Who's that to? TLN: Someone. AGN: Someone who writes back? TLN: Yes.
At the door she says two words to Corin, and they are an order: Bring him back.
Ch. 349: "Something goes, and something else turns up"
On the wall at Harlow's Reach he describes his gift for the first time, and describes it small:
TLN: Always. It isn't much. Something goes, and something else turns up. It's never what you'd want. You lose a good cup and you get a chipped one. You lose a glove and you find somebody else's, a size wrong.
Corin hears the shape of it: "the voice of a person who had been told the size of a thing so early and so kindly that he had never once thought to measure it again for himself".
At dusk he stays at the parapet with his hands flat on the stone and says that something is missing, out on the water. Then the sea parts. See Castelgard.
Ch. 350 and ch. 351: tidying
Through the night he moves people. When the sergeant Raske goes past Vey toward the shield wall, Talon is already standing in his way with a borrowed spear:
RSK: I wasn't asking. TLN: I know. My mother says that. It works better when she does.
Ch. 351 is the fight, and it is not a fight. Raske fires stones out of the wall and Talon puts himself in front of men, and around him things keep arriving to fill gaps: a shield, a bucket, a coil of rope, stones in the wall that do not match. Raske works it out by counting.
RSK: I don't miss. Eleven stones out. Nine holes in the wall. Where'd the other two holes go?
RSK: You're not fighting me. [...] RSK: You're tidying.
He takes a block in the left shoulder, saving the nineteen year old soldier whose family went south.
The manor yard
The chapter opens years earlier, with the first meeting. Corin is about seven and allowed to climb the old wall at the back of the manor yard as far as the third course, on condition that Nurse Orme stands at the bottom. One afternoon she is called into the kitchens. Talon, smaller by a head, is there because his mother brought the mending. He looks at the empty place where the nurse stood, and does not like it, "like a missing tooth", and goes and stands in it.
Corin comes off the sixth course four seconds later and lands on him.
COR: Why were you standing there? TLN: Somebody was supposed to be.
The gap in the sixth course has a stone in it, "darker than the others, and smoother, and very slightly the wrong shape". Nobody ever asks about it.
He went back to the manor the next week, and the week after, and stood near the boy on the wall, and then near the boy at the table, and then beside him, for the rest of his life. It was a choice, in a way.
That last sentence is ch. 272 word for word, "I chose it, in a way", and the chapter is about to take it apart.
The realisation
On his back on the walkway, with Dunne's hand on his good shoulder, he puts it together: the cup, the glove, the inkwell, the stone, and two things nobody had read as his.
- The eleventh match of the Trial (ch. 310). The afterimage upperclassman beat him because "something in him had gone to fill every one of those empty places at once" until the real blade came through.
- Ch. 328. Mira asking for somebody to stand near her, "and Talon there before she finished the sentence. Before. Not quickly. Before."
TLN: I've been standing where somebody else should have been my entire life. I thought it was a choice. DUN: You're concussed. TLN: Very possibly. It still was a choice. It just wasn't only that.
The rule, and the name
TLN: All things are in harmony. When the harmony is broken, when a thing is moved, or a thing is ruined, or a thing is changed from what it was, then something else will come to take its place. It always has. It always will. Nothing is ever simply taken. RSK: What are you rambling on about? TLN: I'll call this ability... Bitter Sweet Symphony.
He hears the whole headland "the way a chord is held", with every gap already being filled "the way a tide fills a footprint". His broken shoulder goes to Raske. Raske's own rod comes down on Raske's head.
The limit
Raske finds it on the third theory:
RSK: You need me to move first. TLN: Yes.
Talon has never once lied about a thing that mattered, and does not start here. Raske stands still. But he breathes, and every breath is a disturbance, "and Talon, who was not a cruel person, found that he would rather not have known it". He does not use the breath. He takes one step, and it is the first gap he has ever made on purpose.
The chain runs nine places and ends under Raske's feet as a slab of sea the size of a flagstone. Raske blows out the whole section of wall as he falls. Talon lets the stones go to shields and timber and chain and none of them to a man. Then Raske stands in the breach he made, and Talon stops holding the door:
TLN: You've made a great many holes tonight. RSK: It was always the same wall-
The wall "from a minute ago" comes back course by course, from the bottom up, in the place Raske is standing. He fires the same stone out three times and it comes back three times. The top course closes over his hand.
What comes after
For a breath the mist holds still, and Talon "very nearly" becomes something larger, which goes back "a long way down and a long way off" and will be there "when he was ready to go and fetch it. He was not ready yet."
He had done that. He noticed that he had done it, and that he could, and that it had been very easy. That was the bitter part. [...] He would mention it, to somebody, someday, when he had found the words, and he thought he already knew who it would be and that she would not look away while he did. That was the sweet part. He had a letter to finish.
The letter is the one on the kitchen table in ch. 348, and "she" is not named. Mira is the only reading the chapters support, and the archive records it as a reading.
The chapter ends with him on his feet again. Out in the mist, where Vey took Corin, something is very quiet, and Talon hears in Corin something he has never heard in him since the manor yard. It was fear.
Ch. 353: he sits down
When it is over he sits beside Corin on the wet stone "with one shoulder held a little stiffly", which is the old break ch. 352 left him with, and says nothing. Corin "knew the weight of him on the stone. He had known it since he was seven."
Corin put his face in his bloody hands, and laughed, and it came out wrong, and Talon let it, and stayed exactly where he was.
Ch. 354: he tells Corin
The captain feels along his shoulder and says something very nearly broke it and somehow did not, and that it will ache in the rain for the rest of his life. Talon says that seems fair. The captain cannot see what ch. 352 did with the break, and Talon does not tell him.
He tells Corin instead, all of it: the cup, the glove, the inkwell, and the headland heard as gaps "in a tune you know". That is how he heard the hope go out of Corin from forty yards off.
COR: Has it got a name? The thing you do. TLN: Bitter Sweet Symphony. COR: That's three words. TLN: Everyone keeps saying that. COR: Who's everyone? TLN: You, and a man who's now part of a wall.
Told that Raske threw the stone that broke Corin's father, he works it out before Corin finishes: Then I've killed him too. The one who threw it.
When Corin tells him about the curse, he takes hold of Corin's wrist, which Corin has never once seen him do, and says that the Fingers will know where he is standing too. "I've stood there since the yard."
At sunrise he sits against the wall "from a minute ago" with a borrowed pencil, writing slowly. He does not cover the page when Corin comes near, as he did at the kitchen table in ch. 348. Corin does not ask, and sits on the side away from the paper.
Ch. 355: the blue door
Agnes has been at the window for some time. She looks at the way he holds his left shoulder, and her face "did a number of things very quickly and then settled into none of them".
COR: I brought him back. TLN: He brought me back, Mother. I didn't help at all. COR: It's the opposite of true. He brought me back. I'd still be on that wall.
She sees something in her son's face that was not there four days earlier, and does not ask about it. She takes Corin's hand instead:
AGN: I wasn't asking, Corin. But thank you.
Ch. 358 confirms where his letter went. Mira holds it all evening in Hollowell and tells the others only that he was there and both of them are all right.
Ch. 361: back at Solmere
He and Corin ride in on one horse, because the second threw a shoe outside Draymere and Corin would not wait the hour. He holds his left shoulder stiffly, which Arthur notices and does not understand. He stays by the horse looking at Mira until she comes to him, and she does not ask, and he does not explain.
Ch. 362
He notices before anyone else that Isolde is watching Corin, because he watched the yard through the forms rather than his own feet, and because "it had to do with gaps, and something being moved, and Talon could hear that now". To Corin he says only Like she can see something, and does not say what.
JUL: Pryce! That shoulder's sitting better than I heard it was. TLN: It aches when it's going to rain.
The website serves Julian's line corrected. As written it says "better than it was in June", but the shoulder broke at Harlow's Reach in ch. 351 and ch. 352, in the summer and away from Solmere.
Ch. 364
When Mira walks off to sit near Isolde, the silence on the good bench "started at Talon and spread outward", and he watches the far end of the refectory for the rest of the meal without drinking. Mira tells the others he did not ask her anything for months.
TLN: It was a while. MRA: Yeah, it was.
Sutton's first sparring list of the year, with abilities allowed, pairs him with Isolde. His face does nothing, but Arthur sees him read the line twice, and across the crowd she finds him and looks at him for a long moment.
Ch. 365: Nothing In Its Place
The spar with Isolde, abilities allowed. He walks out with his hands in his pockets and holds the practice blade "as if he had been handed it to look after for somebody". She becomes three, the ground round him goes to starless night, and something large comes out of it with "a low wet grinding sound like stone being dragged over stone". He tilts his head, listening, and turns toward the one Isolde who is real. The other two and the thing pass through him like smoke.
He is not fast. He moves "as if he had all the time in the world", and every stroke goes through the place he has just left. On the fifth she sweeps his blade out of his hand and sends it spinning into the dark, and he is holding it again, the same practice blade, with the same chip near the tip. Bitter Sweet Symphony fills the gap. He never raises it at her.
ISO: How? TLN: You didn't move anything. ISO: What does that mean? TLN: The three of you. The dark. The thing. None of it moved anything. Nothing got pushed out of its way. Nothing was left empty behind it. You did, though. Every step. You left a hole everywhere you went.
The same ability that hears what has been moved hears what has not: a thing that is not there takes up no room. Arthur sets it beside ch. 263, where Talon could not bring himself to swing at Mira, and decides this is not that. "This was a boy who did not need to."
He comes back to the bench as if from fetching a cup of water, and sighs when the whole row turns to look at him, "the sigh of somebody who has been waiting a long time for a thing he knew would come".